Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain Review

By far one of the most fascinating games in the series. It's also a stand out example of how a long time game creator and studio being engineered out the partnership with his publisher and the art being abandoned before it had a full begginning, middle and end. It's an entry that can get scruntized by long time hardcore fans of the series while also bringing in a different audience that likes it for it's crazy systemic game design. It's one of "those" long running franchise games. What's my position? Yes, the story of MGSV isn't very well written but as someone who got increasingly sick of Kojima's quirky style and his drawn cutscenes with the 4th entry strongly testing my patience, I welcome a game that is tries to expand on Peace Walker's ideas.

MGSV's story is the odd one in a franchise that has endless twist and turns, hard to follow plots, and stories that rely on being quirky but also having deeper themes, the plot here is nothing more than an excuse to do open world missions. You are mainly getting revenge on what Skull Face did in Ground Zeroes. You want exposition? Relegated to audio logs. Want weird boss fights with wacky Marvel Comics styled supervillains that have bizarre military "realism"? Not any to be found here with maybe 2. Want any weird Kojima antics? Mostly downplayed. If you come to MGS for primarily this, Phantom Pain can feel like the weirdest subversion ever.

What's in the cutscenes can almost be Kojima making fun of himself. Skull Face is an over the top theatrical villain almost having the same energy as Palpatine from the Star Wars Prequels where he goes from a calm schemer in Ground Zeroes to endlessly chewing the scenery. The jeep ride might as well have Venom Snake be a surrogate for the audience as he watches him monologue and you subject yourself to listening to it before the gameplay starts after it's done.

Most of the other characters mainly just argue at Mother Base on what they want Venom Snake to do. Where in the 4th game Old Snake being a quiet bore can feel awkward. Here's it's the player doing the actual Big Boss's dirty work. Still due it's place on the timeline it can feel like a filler arc since Outer Heaven is destroyed in the first MSX game. The game is narratively stalling while never giving resolving it's own filler arc and just has a retcon of you being BB's body double be the end.

To TPP's defensive, most of your time is spent playing and the exposition is optional so it's writing shortcomings doesn't stand out as much as MGS3 and 4.

Gameplay is where things really stand out. You got your open world that has outposts scattered over the map like Far Cry 3. You got your updated moveset with abilites like diving, sprint along with the updated CQC controls and animations from Ground Zeroes. You got the updated system with lighting effecting visiblity and as well as the awareness indicators too.

What makes MGSV stand out to this day is how systemic the open world is you have times of day that effect sneaking conditions where guards can see you furthur in the day but harder at night. There's also generators that makes it easier to sneak at night. You can have sandstorms in Afganhistan at random times, it can be daytime than night depending how long the mission goes. Guards can even randomly drive and show up at different times. You can also play the game with certain buddies. You can spend the whole game without ever using D-Dog or Quiet.

The tranq is also encouraged to recruit members for Mother Base and unlike Peace Walker, guards become more and more aware the more use abuse the fulton recovery system.

The various tools adds more to the sandbox. You can use smoke grenades to blind guards, you can CQC chain nearby guards patrolling guards, using distractions to lure guards over to you get a knockout, you can even try to escourt two unconcious NPCs out by making a quick vehicle getaway. I also discovered you can use stealth camo and you can order air strikes or you can create distractions using C4. That also isn't inluding how you can either fulton and kill key targets. CQC interroagte also has more of a use by revealing key information.

There's just so much that can happen in MGSV that I listed some of the many things you can do. Enemies can also put rubber clones of themselves, start wearing helmets or use night vision to see in the dark.

My criticisms are that snipers seem to detect you based on RNG. The logic isn't as consistent as search lights. The game reuses the same outposts a little too much. I would've liked Skull Face to have some captains and then you kill them in a boss level something Ghost Recon Wildlands did later.

The Skulls are annoying with how they are damage sponges and force you into combat and it's better to run away. Chapter 1 is the most coherent part with everything after being busywork for a dull epilogue.

Overall, MGSV has a feel that many open world games now don't have which adds to it's subversive nature


No comments:

Post a Comment